Sony has barely had time to let the dust settle on its announcement to cease physical disc manufacturing by 2028, and the legal challenges are already piling up. Two significant cases are now in motion, and they almost certainly won't be the last.
The $457 million Dutch case just got a bigger argument
A consumer group in the Netherlands, already locked in a legal battle with Sony over its control of the PS Store, says the disc phase-out is exactly the kind of evidence it needed. The group is seeking approximately $457 million in damages, arguing that eliminating physical purchasing options hands Sony unchecked pricing power. With no competing storefronts allowed on PlayStation hardware and physical discs disappearing entirely, the argument is that consumers will have nowhere else to turn.
Here's the thing: that argument has real teeth. Sony stopped allowing third-party retailers to sell digital game codes for PlayStation back around 2019, a decision that already narrowed the competitive field considerably. Physical retail was the last meaningful price check on the PS Store. Remove it, and the pricing leverage question becomes much harder to dismiss.
Mexico's lawmakers prepare an antitrust referral
A separate but closely related challenge is forming in Mexico, where lawmakers are preparing to file a complaint with the country's National Antitrust Commission. The ask is an investigation into Sony's distribution practices following the physical games announcement. The core concern mirrors the Dutch case: a single closed storefront, no external competition, and prices set entirely at Sony's discretion.
Sony's potential counter here is its stated plan to keep supplying retailers with products, likely in the form of codes-in-a-box similar to how GTA 6's physical edition works. The thinking is that if retailers can still sell PlayStation games, even as redeemable codes rather than discs, competition technically still exists. Whether regulators accept that framing is the real question, and it's far from settled.
Why the code-in-a-box defence might not hold
The code-in-a-box model sounds like a compromise, but it has a structural problem. If Sony sets the wholesale price of those codes, third-party retailers have very little room to undercut the PS Store without eating into their own margins. The competitive pressure that physical retail historically created, where a retailer could discount a game independently of the publisher's preferred price, essentially disappears. You end up with a single price point dressed up in cardboard.
What most players miss is that this isn't purely a physical-versus-digital debate. The deeper issue is digital ownership rights, license transfers, and whether consumers have any meaningful recourse if a game gets delisted or a service shuts down. The disc question is just the most visible front.
The bigger legal picture ahead
These two cases are almost certainly the opening moves in a much longer process. Sony holds over 50% of the EU's console gaming market, which puts it in a more exposed position than a niche platform when European regulators start asking questions. The comparison to Apple's App Store battles is already circulating, and Apple did not come out of those fights unscathed in either the EU or Brazil.
The key here is that no definitive regulatory ruling on what constitutes acceptable practice for digital goods on closed platforms exists yet. Until the EU or another major jurisdiction draws a clear line, expect more filings, more investigations, and more pressure from consumer groups across multiple countries. Sony has almost certainly war-gamed these scenarios internally, and the code-in-a-box approach looks like a pre-emptive legal buffer. Whether it works is a question courts will be answering for years.
For PlayStation players trying to get ahead of the platform's shifting direction, our Starfield PS5 guide covering DualSense features and PS5 Pro modes is worth bookmarking as an example of what the all-digital PS5 experience looks like in practice. For broader coverage of what's coming to the platform, the full gaming guides hub has everything you need to stay current as PlayStation's release model continues to evolve.
